- Posts: 14624
Knights of Awakening: Jedi Safe Spaces (Charles McBride)
basically im saying it is not appropriate to hold "defending the system" against anyone, but that this is a charge which applies to everyone if you really want to start throwing it around
how dare you!
Thats what people think here when they defend our way of doing things!! THey have drank our Kool-aid, and not 'tow-the-line'...
Biggest bunch of hogwash ever, but, it makes the accusers feel better, lol...
the american system was designed with the intention that it could essentially be "self correcting" by its citizens. we have acknowledge that the idea of who was a citizen was different then, no doubt, but you can choose to see that as evidence of the "evil empire" or you can choose to recognize the progress that has been made, and choose to see that as evidence of the fact that our country is capable of making healthy progress and healthy change over time, whch means that the empire isnt entirely evil after-all
which is how i choose to see it
I too choose to see it that way...
I feel ANY system can be changed, but, banging on the gates, demanding it from the outside is doomed to fail, most of the time...
Just as in working on our own self improvement, if someone becomes a part of the system to make changes from within (its how I did it to TOTJO), then I feel it is more productive, and less bang-your-head-on-the-wall-ish...
But, its hard to tell that to some people, lol...
We each have our 'ways'...
On walk-about...
Sith ain't Evil...
Jedi ain't Saints....
"Bake or bake not. There is no fry" - Sean Ching
Rite: PureLand
Former Memeber of the TOTJO Council
Master: Jasper_Ward
Current Apprentices: Viskhard, DanWerts, Llama Su, Trisskar
Former Apprentices: Knight Learn_To_Know, Knight Edan, Knight Brenna, Knight Madhatter
Please Log in to join the conversation.
- OB1Shinobi
- Offline
- Banned
- Posts: 4394
Jamie Stick wrote: ...
3. That personal suffering means there is no ethno-cultural suffering or is equivalent to ethno-cultural suffering.
...
In response to the idea that personal suffering negates ethno-cultural suffering or is equivalent to ethno-cultural suffering. This one ties into my conception of what racism means, but stated another way I would say, "just because white supremacy exists does not mean you are incapable of suffering hardships. It only means you do not suffer hardships because of being white."
keeping in mind that this was a response to my previous posts, i think i should clarify something that i said which i believe to be the source of this point - i didnt previously, and do not currently, deny the reality of what you are referring to as "ethno-cultural suffering" (but, for the record, i think that phrase is pretentious a.h.), what i said basically was that 1) not every person of any race has the same cultural experience as every other person of that race; factors other than race, such as socio-economic status, education, location, social and commercial networks, upbringing, and even personal attitude, all make a big difference in the overall experience of any individual over the duration of a lifetime
and that 2) it is a very small percentage of individuals within any race who identify with all other non white races simply on the basis of not being white
in other words, i dont see a lot of hispanics and asians and blacks looking at each other and saying "yeah, we all have the same cultural experience"
im no longer young however, and the millennial generation might feel more disposed towards this, but i have witnessed racism and prejudice from every race and have not met any asians anywhere who identify with blacks at all, nor blacks who identify with asians, nor mexicans who identify with either: "POC" is not a race
it is a generalization of several generalizations
definitely i recognize that individuals of minority races are typically (read: statistically) going to be more likely to experience more suffering as a result of their race than whites will: afaik, thats not being disputed by any serious, competent observer on any side of these arguments, and i would dismiss out of hand anyone who suggests that there is no more racism in america or that racism isnt still a problem
my understanding is this: a black kid born to a drug prostitute in the slums of chicago has got quite a different experience of what it means to be black in america than will/do the grandchildren of Colin Powell
http://www.biography.com/people/colin-powell-9445708#retirement
Colin Powell was the first African American appointed as the U.S. Secretary of State, and the first, and so far the only, to serve on the Joint Chiefs of Staff.
Synopsis
Colin Luther Powell is a United States statesman and a retired four-star general in the United States Army. He was the 65th United States Secretary of State (2001-2005), serving under President George W. Bush. He was the first African American appointed to that position. He was the first, and so far the only, African American to serve on the Joint Chiefs of Staff.
Early Military Career
Military official/diplomat. Born Colin Luther Powell on April 5, 1937, in Harlem, New York. The son of Jamaican immigrants Luther and Maud Powell, Colin was raised in the South Bronx. Powell was educated in the New York City public schools, and graduated from Morris High School in 1954 without any definite plans for where he wanted to go in life. It was at City College of New York, where Powell studied geology, that he found his calling—in the Reserve Officers' Training Corps (ROTC). He soon became commander of his unit. This experience set him on a military career and gave him structure and direction in his life.
After graduation in 1958, Powell was commissioned as a second lieutenant in the U.S. Army. While stationed at Fort Devens, Massachusetts, Colin Powell met Alma Vivian Johnson of Birmingham, Alabama, and they married in 1962. The couple now has three children: son Michael, and daughters Linda and Annemarie. That same year, he was one of 16,000 advisers sent to South Vietnam by President John Kennedy. In 1963, Powell was wounded by a punji-stick booby trap while patrolling the Vietnamese-Laotian border. During this first tour of duty, he was awarded a Purple Heart and, a year later, a Bronze Star.
While on his second Vietnam tour of duty from 1968 to 1969, the 31-year-old Army major was given the assignment of investigating the My Lai massacre. In this incident, more than 300 civilians were killed by U.S. Army forces. Colin Powell's report seemed to refute the allegations of wrongdoing and stated, "Relations between American soldiers and the Vietnamese people are excellent." Also during this tour in Vietnam, Powell was injured in a helicopter crash. Despite his injury, he managed to rescue his comrades from the burning helicopter, for which he was awarded the Soldier's Medal. In all, Powell has received 11 military decorations, including the Legion of Merit.
Reagan and Bush Administrations
Powell earned an MBA at George Washington University, in Washington, D.C., and won a White House fellowship in 1972. He was assigned to the Office of Management and Budget during the Nixon administration and made a lasting impression on Caspar Weinberger and Frank Carlucci. Both men would consult Powell for advice when they served as secretary of defense and national security adviser, respectively, in the Reagan administration.
Colonel Colin Powell served a tour of duty in Korea in 1973 as a battalion commander and after that, he obtained a staff job at the Pentagon. After study at the Army War College, he was promoted to brigadier general and commanded a brigade of the 101st Airborne Division. In the Carter administration, he was an assistant to the deputy secretary of defense and the secretary of energy. Promoted to major general, he again assisted Frank Carlucci at the Department of Defense during the transition from the Carter to the Reagan administration. He then served as senior military aide to Secretary of Defense Caspar Weinberger, helping to coordinate the invasion of Granada and the bombing of Libya.
In 1987, Powell became national security adviser, a post he held for the duration of the Reagan administration. While there, he coordinated technical and policy advisers during Reagan's summit meetings with Soviet President Gorbachev and his conferences to topple the pro-Communist Sandinista government in Nicaragua. It was discovered that the administration had arranged for covert and illegal shipments of U.S. weapons to Iran in exchange for the release of hostages. Proceeds from the sale of the weapons would go to support the counter-insurgency movement in Nicaragua, which was aimed at toppling the Sandinistas. Such support had been prohibited by Congress since 1982. Powell was asked to testify before Congress about the incident, but he was not implicated in any wrongdoing.
In 1989, President George H. W. Bush appointed General Colin Powell as Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff. The post is the highest military position in the Department of Defense, and Powell was the first African-American officer to receive that distinction. General Powell became a national figure during Desert Shield and Desert Storm operations in Iraq. As chief military strategist, he developed what became known as the "Powell Doctrine," an approach to military conflicts that advocates using overwhelming force to maximize success and minimize casualties. He continued as chairman of the Joint Chiefs in the first few months of the Clinton administration. He publicly disagreed with the president on the issue of admitting gays into the military, although he eventually agreed to the "don't ask, don't tell" compromise.
Iraq Controversy
Colin Powell retired from the Army in 1993. In 1994, he joined Senator Sam Nunn and former President Jimmy Carter on a last-minute peacekeeping expedition to Haiti, which resulted in the end of military rule and a peaceful return to elected government in that country. In 1995, he published a best-selling autobiography, My American Journey, which chronicles his life and its influences, the ins and outs of military bureaucracy, and what he learned in his life about personal rules and character. From 1997 to 2000, he was chairman of America's Promise, a nonprofit organization dedicated to fostering character and competence in young people. Powell and his wife, Alma, now co-chair the organization, which has a presence in more than 500 communities in all 50 states.
In 2000, President George W. Bush appointed Colin Powell secretary of state, and Powell was unanimously confirmed by the U.S. Senate. At that time, this was the highest rank in civilian government ever held by an African-American. During his tenure, Powell came under fire for his role in building the case for the 2003 invasion of Iraq. Initially, Powell had serious misgivings about President Bush's plan to invade Iraq and overthrow Saddam Hussein. Powell believed the policy of containment was sufficient to control the Iraqi regime. He warned Bush that a military invasion would consume the president's first term and that if an attack were to occur, it should use overwhelming force and have broad international support. This support would be key to the rebuilding of Iraq.
Bush decided to go to war and, in a crucial moment, Powell agreed to support the president. To advance the case for war with the international community, Powell appeared before the U.N. Security Council in February 2003 to present evidence that Iraq had concealed an ongoing weapons development program. Powell's reputation for integrity helped convince many in Congress and the country that Iraq posed an imminent threat.
For the remainder of Bush's first term, Colin Powell tried to establish an international coalition to assist in the rebuilding of Iraq. In September 2004, he testified before Congress that the intelligence sources he used in his February presentation to the United Nations were "wrong" and it was unlikely that Saddam had any stockpiles of weapons of mass destruction. Powell advised the committee of the necessity to reform the intelligence community in order to improve its gathering and analysis. In 2004, after acknowledging it was unlikely that Iraq possessed stockpiles of weapons of mass destruction, Powell announced his resignation as secretary of state. National Security Adviser Condoleezza Rice was his successor.
Retirement
Since his retirement, Powell has remained vocal on political topics, openly criticizing the Bush administration on a number of issues. In September 2006, Powell joined moderate Senate Republicans in supporting more rights and better treatment for detainees at the Guantanamo detention facility. In October 2008, Colin Powell made headlines again when he announced his endorsement of Barack Obama for president.
Powell has also spent much of his retirement in the business community. In 2006, he was a speaker at a special series called Get Motivated, along with former New York Mayor Rudolph Giuliani. Powell also joined Kleiner Perkins Caufield & Byers, a Silicon Valley venture capital firm, as a "strategic limited partner." Most recently he joined the board of directors at Steve Case's new company, Revolution Health, a health-related portal site and social network that provides online tools to help people better manage their health.
Colin Powell has spent much of his life inspiring many with his leadership skills and life experiences. Along with his wife, Powell began America's Promise Alliance, as part of their dedication to the wellbeing of children and youth of all socioeconomic levels and their commitment to seeing that young people receive the resources necessary to succeed.
Colin Powell began his American journey from ordinary circumstances. His close-knit family provided support and a caring environment during his childhood. He found his calling in the military, and his entire adult life has been in the service of his country. As a soldier, he was committed to protecting the nation and advancing democratic values. While he gravitated toward support roles early in his career, his organizational talent and pragmatic outlook were recognized by those who placed him in key government advisory roles.
the main points of my position are these:
1) Colin Powell's generation faced less racism than the Tuskegee Airmen but greater racism than millennials do, (probably without ever thinking he was so traumatized that he should demand his white allies to leave the room) and 2) the key to decreasing racism in the coming generations is for the current generation to further succeed in important cultural fields such as medicine, technology, science, politics, law, law enforcement, military, art, entertainment, and what can be generically labeled "business" or "entrepreneurship"
http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2016/07/the-myth-of-the-millennial-entrepreneur/490058/
and that every white person is NOT personally responsible for the entire history of racism, (just as every white person is not equally responsible for the abolishment of slavery) and shifting the focus of the conversation in that direction takes it away from where it needs to be, which is how to open up social and economic access to those who dont have it (and i mean to the poor in general, much more than to any specific race)
it is literally the exact same kind of thinking to label "white culture" as being fundamentally violent and oppressive as it is to label "black culture" as being fundamentally violent and criminal: it is a skewed and resentful view which is more interested in hurting the enemy group than in building ANY group
the solution is the same today as it was 50 years ago: promote the idea that all individuals should be judged, "not by the color of their skin, but by the content of their character" and the racial maturity that americans need to develop is that which comes as a natural result of accumulated experiences of cooperation and success - we need to see each other and be able to treat each other as friends, partners, and allies
we need to invest in each other, all of us
thats always been the right message, and those who work in that direction are the ones who are helping to make society better, and those who work to oppose that basic message arent
People are complicated.
Please Log in to join the conversation.