French move to ban prostitution by punishing clien
-
- Visitor
-
07 Dec 2011 07:30 #45607
by
Well increasing the legality of it increases the number and increases the john's at ease feeling of going out to get it. Now if they did have prescreening, and a brothel set up with security and for some reason every prostitute gets off the street to do this then it would make sense. But since the same girls are going to be on the street because of drug problems or medical problems then it increases those numbers because hypothetically a girl loses a job at a brothel, does she just stop? Of course not she goes onto the street. This makes it more laxed on laws on this subject.
Now think of it as an American point of view, our government would NEVER allow brothels. They would have to be in the middle of nowhere far away from churches, schools, and so on otherwise their would be a complaint every other day. Now if it was downtown in a dirty area this doesn't help things at all. The girls leaving work will end up having pimps once again because they would have an apartment down the street from the brothel and would see it as a untaxed extra couple bucks with a protection from a pimp. Now you would have 2 times as many call girls walking down the street because it is more or less more legal than before. In America this wouldn't work whatsoever. I remember when abortion was a gigantic thing here (and it still is of some sorts) let alone prostitution.
These laws would never work where drugs and corruption already exist in that "sector" of our country. Now if it was from the start without the drugs thrown in then there may have been a shot but the way things are now most are meth heads anyways trying to score some cash for the next high. This market is already too polluted to have any positive effect on things.
Replied by on topic Re: French move to ban prostitution by punishing clien
Mark Anjuu wrote: The prevention of rape or murder of a prostitute has nothing to do with the legality of prostitution itself but everything to do with the state of mind of the perpetrator. If someone's gonna do it, they'll do it whatever the situation. If brothels and sex workers were officially regulated (through legalisation), surely their workplace environments would be safer. I mean, the Risk Assessment requirements for spillages alone must be worth it...
Well increasing the legality of it increases the number and increases the john's at ease feeling of going out to get it. Now if they did have prescreening, and a brothel set up with security and for some reason every prostitute gets off the street to do this then it would make sense. But since the same girls are going to be on the street because of drug problems or medical problems then it increases those numbers because hypothetically a girl loses a job at a brothel, does she just stop? Of course not she goes onto the street. This makes it more laxed on laws on this subject.
Now think of it as an American point of view, our government would NEVER allow brothels. They would have to be in the middle of nowhere far away from churches, schools, and so on otherwise their would be a complaint every other day. Now if it was downtown in a dirty area this doesn't help things at all. The girls leaving work will end up having pimps once again because they would have an apartment down the street from the brothel and would see it as a untaxed extra couple bucks with a protection from a pimp. Now you would have 2 times as many call girls walking down the street because it is more or less more legal than before. In America this wouldn't work whatsoever. I remember when abortion was a gigantic thing here (and it still is of some sorts) let alone prostitution.
These laws would never work where drugs and corruption already exist in that "sector" of our country. Now if it was from the start without the drugs thrown in then there may have been a shot but the way things are now most are meth heads anyways trying to score some cash for the next high. This market is already too polluted to have any positive effect on things.
Please Log in to join the conversation.
-
- Visitor
-
-
- Visitor
-
-
- Visitor
-
-
- Visitor
-
-
- Visitor
-
